Thermal spray coating is a surface engineering process used to apply protective or functional materials to components and structures. Among the commonly used methods, arc spray and flame spray are two established techniques for depositing metallic coatings. Although both use heat to melt coating materials and propel them onto a prepared surface, they differ in their heat sources, equipment, operating costs and coating characteristics.
Understanding the difference between arc spray and flame spray helps engineers, maintenance teams and industrial buyers select a suitable coating process for corrosion protection, component restoration and other surface treatment requirements. This guide explains how both processes work, compares their advantages and limitations, and outlines the factors to consider when choosing between them.
What Is Thermal Spray Coating?
Thermal spray coating is a surface treatment process in which a material is heated until it becomes molten or semi-molten and then projected onto a prepared surface. The deposited particles flatten, cool and accumulate to form a coating layer. Depending on the material and process, the coating can improve corrosion resistance, wear resistance and component service life.
Thermal spraying is used across industries where metal surfaces face environmental exposure, friction, abrasion or other operating conditions. Common coating materials include metals, alloys, ceramics and certain composite materials. The final coating properties depend on the feedstock, spray equipment, process parameters and surface preparation.
How Does the Thermal Spray Coating Process Work?
The thermal spray coating process involves preparing a component, feeding coating material into a spray gun, heating the material and directing the resulting particles onto the surface. The particles flatten and build up in successive layers to create the required coating thickness. Proper surface preparation and process control are essential for achieving consistent coating quality.
The typical stages include:
- Surface preparation: Remove oil, grease, rust, dirt and other contaminants. Grit blasting is commonly used to create a suitable surface profile.
- Material feeding: Supply the selected coating material to the spray gun in wire, rod or powder form, depending on the process.
- Heating and melting: Use a suitable heat source to melt or soften the feedstock.
- Particle projection: Propel the heated material towards the prepared substrate.
- Coating formation: Allow the particles to flatten, cool and accumulate on the surface.
- Finishing and inspection: Check coating thickness, appearance, adhesion and other specified quality requirements.
The coating does not generally form through conventional fusion welding with the base material. Its adhesion is primarily associated with mechanical bonding and the condition of the prepared surface.
What Is Arc Spray Coating?
Arc spray coating, also called electric arc spraying or twin-wire arc spraying, is a thermal spray process that uses an electrical arc to melt two consumable metal wires. Compressed air or another suitable atomising gas breaks the molten metal into fine droplets and propels them towards a prepared substrate, where they form a protective coating.
The process uses two electrically charged wires with opposite polarity. As the wires meet at the spray gun, an electric arc forms and melts their tips. The molten material is then atomised and deposited onto the component. Since the coating material itself becomes part of the electrical circuit, the conventional process requires electrically conductive wire feedstock.
How Does the Arc Spray Process Work?
In the arc spray process, two metal wires are continuously fed towards an electrical arc generated at the spray gun. The arc melts the wire tips, while compressed gas atomises and accelerates the molten particles towards the substrate. The deposited droplets cool and build up into a metallic coating with the required thickness.
The process generally follows these steps:
- Two compatible metal wires are fed through the spray gun.
- An electrical potential creates an arc between the wire tips.
- The heat generated by the arc melts the incoming wire material.
- Compressed air or another suitable gas atomises the molten metal.
- The particles travel towards the prepared component.
- Successive passes build the coating to the specified thickness.
Arc spraying is commonly used for metallic coatings, including zinc and aluminium, in suitable corrosion-protection applications. It is also used for selected component restoration and surface engineering requirements.
Advantages of Arc Spray Coating
Arc spray coating is widely used where metallic coatings need to be deposited efficiently over suitable surfaces. Its electrical heating mechanism and continuous wire feeding make it useful for larger coating jobs and industrial applications. The process can provide comparatively high deposition rates, making it an option for projects where productivity and coating coverage are important considerations.
Key advantages include:
- High deposition productivity: It can deposit metallic coating material at relatively high rates.
- Suitable for large surfaces: It is used for coating structures and components with substantial surface areas.
- No fuel-gas flame: The process uses electrical energy rather than a combustion flame as its primary heat source.
- Flexible metallic feedstock: Suitable conductive wires can be selected according to the application.
- Corrosion-protection applications: Zinc and aluminium coatings are used on suitable steel structures.
- Component restoration: Selected worn or undersized components can be rebuilt using appropriate spray materials.
Limitations of Arc Spray Coating
Although arc spraying offers several industrial advantages, it is not suitable for every coating material or working environment. Conventional twin-wire arc spraying requires electrically conductive wire feedstock, and its operation involves electrical equipment, compressed gas and appropriate fume extraction. Coating performance also depends on preparation, spray parameters and the material selected.
Important limitations include:
- Conventional systems are generally limited to electrically conductive wire feedstock.
- The process generates fumes and other airborne emissions that require suitable extraction and safety controls.
- Electrical equipment and compressed-air systems require proper operation and maintenance.
- Coating quality can vary with wire condition, spray distance, operating parameters and surface preparation.
- It may not be suitable where the specified coating requires the characteristics of a different thermal spray process.
What Is Flame Spray Coating?
Flame spray coating is a thermal spraying method that uses the heat produced by burning a fuel gas with oxygen to melt coating material. The feedstock can be supplied as wire, rod or powder, depending on the equipment. Compressed air or another suitable gas then propels the heated particles towards a prepared surface.
Common fuel gases include acetylene, propane and hydrogen, selected according to the equipment and process requirements. The material melts or becomes sufficiently softened in the flame before being projected onto the component. Flame spraying is used for metallic coatings, selected wear-resistant layers and the restoration of suitable components.
How Does the Flame Spray Process Work?
The flame spray process uses a controlled combustion flame to heat the coating material before projecting it onto the substrate. Depending on the spray equipment, the feedstock is supplied as wire, rod or powder. The heated particles are carried towards the prepared surface, where they cool and form a coating layer.
The main stages are:
- Feedstock selection: Choose a compatible wire, rod or powder according to the coating requirement.
- Fuel and oxygen supply: Set up the required gas supply and combustion system.
- Material feeding: Introduce the coating material into the spray gun.
- Heating: Use the combustion flame to melt or soften the feedstock.
- Atomisation and projection: Propel the heated material towards the prepared substrate using the appropriate gas flow.
- Coating build-up: Apply successive passes to achieve the specified coating thickness.
The exact operating procedure varies between wire-flame and powder-flame equipment. Material selection, flame settings and spray distance must be controlled according to the application.
Advantages of Flame Spray Coating
Flame spray coating is valued for its relatively simple equipment, operational flexibility and ability to process different feedstock forms. It can be used for selected metallic, alloy and other compatible coatings, making it suitable for component repair and protective surface treatments. The process can also be adapted to different job requirements through appropriate equipment and material selection.
Its main advantages include:
- Relatively low equipment investment: Conventional flame spray systems can have lower initial equipment costs than some alternative processes.
- Feedstock flexibility: Depending on the equipment, wire, rod and powder materials can be sprayed.
- Operational flexibility: Suitable systems can be used for workshop and certain on-site applications.
- Component restoration: It can be used to rebuild selected worn or undersized components.
- Different coating materials: Compatible metals, alloys and other materials can be selected for specific applications.
- Established technology: It is a conventional thermal spray method with a long history of industrial use.
Limitations of Flame Spray Coating
Flame spraying is useful for many conventional coating applications, but its results depend on the selected material, equipment and operating conditions. Compared with some higher-energy thermal spray processes, conventional flame-sprayed coatings can have greater porosity and lower bond strength. The combustion flame also introduces heat into the work area, making process control and fire safety important.
Some limitations to consider are:
- Coating adhesion and density may be lower than those achieved by certain higher-energy processes.
- Porosity and oxide content can be higher, depending on the feedstock and spray conditions.
- Fuel gases and oxygen require appropriate storage, handling and safety measures.
- Heat transfer to the component must be considered, especially for temperature-sensitive substrates.
- Coating performance depends on correct surface preparation and process control.
Arc Spray vs Flame Spray: Key Differences
Arc spray and flame spray both involve the deposition of molten coating material onto a prepared surface. The two processes differ in the energy source and the way in which the coating material is heated. Arc spray works by melting two electrically conductive wires via an electrical arc. Flame spray on the other hand uses combustion gases and can process wire, rod or powder. The differences between the two processes have an impact on productivity, the equipment required and the properties of the resulting coating.
The following comparison highlights their main differences:
| Comparison factor | Arc spray coating | Flame spray coating |
| Heat source | Electrical arc | Fuel-gas combustion flame |
| Feedstock | Usually two conductive wires | Wire, rod or powder, depending on equipment |
| Material melting | Electrical arc melts wire tips | Combustion flame heats the feedstock |
| Atomisation | Compressed air or suitable gas | Compressed air or suitable gas |
| Deposition productivity | Generally high for suitable metallic feedstock | Moderate to high, depending on equipment and material |
| Equipment | Power source, wire feed system and spray gun | Fuel-gas system, feed mechanism and spray gun |
| Operating requirements | Electrical power and compressed gas | Fuel gas, oxygen and appropriate gas controls |
| Coating characteristics | Often higher bond strength and deposition rate than conventional flame spray | Can have higher porosity and lower bond strength than arc spray |
| Common applications | Metallic coatings, structural corrosion protection and selected repairs | Metallic coatings, component restoration and selected wear applications |
Actual coating properties and production rates depend on the material, equipment, spray parameters and application. The comparison describes general tendencies rather than guaranteed results.
Which Is Better: Arc Spray or Flame Spray?
Arc spray is often the method of choice when you’re looking at productive deposition of metal onto large areas, flame spray can be the right option when you’re more concerned with equipment flexibility, feedstock availability or the ability to restore components. Neither process is in any way superior. The right one to use will depend on the coating requirements, the condition of the substrate, the nature of the production and the service environment the component is going to be in.
Consider arc spray when:
- The coating material is available in a suitable conductive wire form.
- The project involves large steel surfaces or structural components.
- Higher metallic coating deposition productivity is important.
- Zinc or aluminium coatings are required for a suitable corrosion-protection application.
Consider flame spray when:
- The required material is compatible with the selected flame spray equipment.
- Wire, rod or powder feedstock flexibility is useful.
- The project involves selected repair or surface restoration work.
- Equipment investment and operating arrangements are important selection factors.
For critical applications, the process should be selected against a defined coating specification rather than price or deposition speed alone.
Industrial Applications of Arc Spray and Flame Spray
Arc spray and flame spray are both used in an industrial context where you’re looking at applying a protective coating to a component, or restoring a component’s surface or improving its resistance to the conditions it will be operating in. The application of either process will depend upon the coating material and the performance requirements of the component in question. Both can be used to deposit a metallic coating but the correct process to use will depend on the substrate, the exposure conditions and the required coating properties.
| Industry or application | Arc spray applications | Flame spray applications |
| Infrastructure | Zinc or aluminium coatings on suitable steel structures | Selected metallic protective coatings |
| Marine environments | Protective metallic coatings on suitable structural components | Selected repair and coating applications |
| Power generation | Corrosion protection for suitable steel components | Restoration of selected equipment parts |
| Manufacturing | Metallic surface coatings and component restoration | Repair of worn or undersized components |
| Heavy engineering | Protective coatings on large fabricated structures | Selected wear-resistant and repair coatings |
The suitability of either process depends on the coating material, required thickness, substrate preparation and environmental exposure. A coating specification should define the necessary performance and inspection criteria before work begins.
Role of Zinc Wire in Thermal Spray Metalizing
Zinc wire is the feedstock of choice for thermal spray metalising (particularly for the application of zinc coatings to suitable steel for atmospheric corrosion protection). The wire is melted and atomised via the appropriate arc or flame spray equipment. The resulting zinc deposit is a protective coating, the performance of which is a function of the quality of the coating and the conditions to which it is exposed.
Zinc thermal spray metalizing is widely used to provide corrosion protection to suitable steel surfaces. The effectiveness of the coating depends on material selection, surface preparation, application quality and the specified coating thickness. For a deeper understanding, read our guide to corrosion protection using zinc thermal spray wire.
Zinc thermal spray metalizing is used on suitable structures such as:
- Steel bridges and infrastructure
- Industrial steel structures
- Storage tanks and fabricated components
- Selected marine and coastal steel structures
- Other steel surfaces requiring protective metallic coatings
The choice between arc and flame spraying for zinc depends on the project specification, equipment, access, productivity and required coating characteristics.
For applications involving zinc wire, explore zinc wire for thermal spray metalizing from Kothari Metsol. This product page is the relevant commercial resource for readers who want to learn about zinc wire used in thermal spray applications.
Factors to Consider When Selecting a Thermal Spray Process
Selecting a thermal spray process requires more than comparing equipment costs or deposition rates. The coating must meet the component’s functional requirements and remain suitable under its actual operating conditions. Engineers should evaluate the substrate, coating material, surface preparation, expected exposure, required thickness and inspection criteria before deciding between arc spray and flame spray.
Important selection factors include:
- Substrate material: Check whether the component material is compatible with the proposed coating process and its heat input.
- Coating material: Confirm that the selected material is available in a feedstock form suitable for the equipment.
- Operating environment: Consider moisture, salt exposure, chemicals, temperature, abrasion and other service conditions.
- Required coating properties: Define the required adhesion, thickness, porosity, corrosion resistance and wear performance.
- Surface preparation: Specify the cleaning and surface roughness requirements before spraying.
- Production requirements: Compare deposition productivity, equipment access and project size.
- Quality inspection: Establish suitable checks for coating thickness, adhesion, visual defects and other specified properties.
- Safety requirements: Account for electrical hazards, fuel gases, fumes, ventilation and personal protective equipment.
A documented coating specification helps ensure that the selected process is appropriate for the intended application.
Why Surface Preparation Matters in Thermal Spray Coating
Surface preparation is one of the most critical stages in thermal spray coating as the deposited material is so much dependent on the condition of the substrate for adhesion. Oil, rust, dust, moisture and all the other sorts of contamination can have a detrimental effect on the coating. Cleaning and appropriate roughening (typically via grit blasting) will create a surface that will allow for good, consistent coating attachment.
Before spraying, the component should be assessed for:
- Oil, grease and other surface contaminants
- Rust, mill scale and existing coating residues
- Surface profile and cleanliness
- Moisture and environmental conditions
- Masking requirements for areas that must remain uncoated
The prepared surface should be protected from contamination before coating begins. The specified surface preparation method and acceptable surface condition should be documented for the project.
Quality Control and Inspection of Thermal Spray Coatings
Thermal spray coating quality should be assessed in the context of the application and the relevant project specification. A coating that appears uniform may still have problems with thickness, adhesion, porosity or coverage. Inspection therefore needs to include appropriate checks prior to, during and after spraying to ensure that the coating meets the required performance criteria.
Common quality-control checks include:
- Visual inspection: Identify bare areas, uneven coverage, visible defects and surface irregularities.
- Coating thickness measurement: Confirm that the deposited layer meets the specified thickness.
- Adhesion testing: Evaluate coating bond strength using an appropriate test method where required.
- Surface preparation checks: Verify cleanliness and surface profile before spraying.
- Process monitoring: Record relevant operating parameters and material details.
- Documentation: Maintain inspection records, material traceability and process information.
The inspection method and acceptance limits should be defined by the applicable coating specification. Not every test is required for every application.
Cost Comparison: Equipment, Running Costs and Cost per m²
The cost of arc spray and flame spray coating is a function of the equipment required (arc spray requires an electrical power source and wire feeding equipment, flame spray requires fuel gas and oxygen), the coating material, the surface preparation, the labour, the application time and the inspection. The actual cost per square metre will of course vary according to the individual project.
Equipment Cost: Arc Spray vs Flame Spray
The capital outlay for a thermal spray system is more than just the spray gun. You also have to take into account the supporting equipment, the material handling, the safety arrangements and the inspection equipment.
| Cost component | Arc spray | Flame spray |
| Main equipment | Arc spray gun, power source and wire feeder | Flame spray gun and feedstock delivery system |
| Energy supply | Electrical power | Fuel gas and oxygen |
| Supporting equipment | Compressed air, cables and control equipment | Gas regulators, hoses and gas supply arrangements |
| Consumables | Metallic spray wires, air filters and other operating supplies | Spray wires, rods or powders, fuel gas and oxygen |
| Maintenance | Electrical components, wire-feeding system and spray gun | Gas delivery system, spray gun and feed mechanism |
Conventional flame spray equipment may have a lower initial purchase cost in some configurations. However, equipment prices vary significantly with capacity, automation, manufacturer, material compatibility and intended use. A meaningful comparison should consider the complete installation rather than the spray gun alone.
Running Costs of Arc and Flame Spray
Running costs include all recurring expenses involved in preparing, spraying, inspecting and finishing the coated surface. Arc spray operating costs are influenced by electrical consumption, wire usage, compressed air, labour and maintenance. Flame spray costs include feedstock, fuel gas, oxygen, labour, equipment maintenance and the time required to complete the coating.
The main operating cost factors are:
- Coating material consumption: Depends on the material, specified coating thickness, deposition efficiency and overspray.
- Energy consumption: Includes electricity for arc spraying or fuel gas and oxygen for flame spraying.
- Surface preparation: Includes abrasive blasting, cleaning, masking and associated labour.
- Labour: Depends on operator experience, component geometry and accessibility.
- Equipment maintenance: Includes replacement parts, servicing and calibration.
- Inspection and testing: Covers coating thickness measurement, adhesion testing and other specified checks.
- Post-treatment: May include sealing, finishing or additional coating layers where required.
How to Calculate Thermal Spray Coating Cost per m²
The cost per square metre should be calculated using the total project cost divided by the actual coated surface area. The estimate should include material consumption, labour, surface preparation, equipment operation, energy, inspection and finishing. This approach provides a more realistic comparison than considering only the price of spray wire or fuel.
A practical estimation framework is:
Cost per m² = Total coating project cost ÷ Total coated surface area
A project estimate can be organised as follows:
| Cost category | What to include |
| Material | Wire, rod or powder consumption |
| Surface preparation | Abrasive, blasting equipment and labour |
| Equipment operation | Equipment usage and operating expenses |
| Energy | Electricity, compressed air, fuel gas and oxygen |
| Labour | Preparation, spraying and finishing time |
| Quality control | Inspection, testing and documentation |
| Additional work | Masking, access equipment, sealing and repairs |
For an accurate quotation, specify the substrate, coating material, required thickness, surface condition, total area and site location. Also clarify whether the quoted rate includes blasting, masking, sealing, inspection and taxes. Comparing quotations with the same scope is essential when evaluating the cost of arc spray versus flame spray.
Arc Spray or Flame Spray: Which Should You Choose?
The choice between arc spray and flame spray is going to be dictated by the coating material, the required deposition rate, the component geometry, the operating environment and the project specs. Arc spraying is often the process of choice when you’re looking at a productive application of a metallic wire coating. Flame spraying on the other hand is the more flexible of the two in that it can be used with a range of compatible wire, rod and powder feedstocks. The right process is the one that meets the required coating performance.
When Should You Choose Arc Spray?
Arc spray is generally worth looking at when you’re dealing with large steel surfaces and you need a metallic coating. It’s particularly applicable where the material in question is available as a suitable conductive wire. The relatively high deposition rate can be an advantage in the case of large scale infrastructure and industrial corrosion protection work.
Choose arc spray when:
- The application requires zinc, aluminium or another suitable metallic wire coating.
- A relatively high deposition rate is important.
- Large structural surfaces need coating.
- Electrical power and compressed air are available.
- The project specification supports arc-sprayed coating.
When Should You Choose Flame Spray?
Flame spray can be the appropriate process when the coating material, the size of the component or the nature of the repair is such that a combustion process is the way to go. It has the ability to take different forms of feedstock depending on the equipment and this gives it flexibility for a range of protective coatings and component repair applications.
Choose flame spray when:
- The selected material is compatible with wire, rod or powder flame spray equipment.
- The project involves smaller surfaces or selected repair work.
- Equipment flexibility is an important consideration.
- The application specification accepts the expected coating properties.
- Fuel gas and oxygen can be supplied and handled safely.
Quick Decision Table
| Project requirement | Process to evaluate |
| High productivity for metallic wire coatings | Arc spray |
| Zinc or aluminium coating on suitable steel | Arc spray or wire flame spray |
| Different feedstock forms | Flame spray, depending on equipment |
| Large structural coating areas | Often arc spray |
| Selected component restoration | Flame spray or another suitable thermal spray method |
| Specific coating performance requirements | Select according to the approved specification |
The final selection should be based on engineering requirements and not on a general assumption that one method always produces a better coating. Where the component is critical, conduct a procedure assessment or trial coating before full-scale application.
Applications of Arc Spray and Flame Spray by Industry
Arc spray and flame spray are used in a wide variety of industries for corrosion protection, surface restoration and the application of functional coatings to metal components. The choice of process will depend on the coating material, the substrate, the service environment and the required performance. Arc spray is generally used for the application of metallic coatings to large scale structures, flame spray is also used in a number of instances for component repair and for the application of protective surface coatings.
| Industry | Arc spray applications | Flame spray applications |
| Infrastructure | Zinc and aluminium coatings on suitable steel bridges and structures | Selected protective coatings and repair work |
| Marine | Corrosion-protection coatings on suitable steel structures and components | Selected maintenance and coating applications |
| Oil and gas | Protective coatings for suitable structural steel and equipment | Selected component restoration and repair |
| Power generation | Coatings for suitable steel structures and industrial components | Repair and restoration of selected equipment parts |
| Manufacturing | Metallic surface coatings and dimensional restoration | Selected wear-resistant coatings and component repairs |
| Heavy engineering | Protective metallic coatings on fabricated structures | Repair of compatible machine components |
| Transportation | Coatings on suitable structural and industrial components | Selected component restoration applications |
Infrastructure and Structural Steel
Steel bridges, fabricated structures and industrial installations are all likely to be exposed to moisture, atmospheric pollutants and variable weather conditions. Zinc and aluminium thermal spray coatings are used on appropriate steel surfaces to provide a metallic form of corrosion protection. Arc spray and wire flame spray are the established methods of applying these coatings where they are specified.
Marine and Coastal Applications
Marine and coastal structures are subject to very severe exposure conditions in terms of moisture and airborne salts. Thermal sprayed metallic coatings can be considered for appropriate steel components, as long as the coating system is selected in accordance with the exposure category, the design and the maintenance plan.
Manufacturing and Heavy Engineering
Thermal spraying is also used in the manufacturing environment for selected component restoration and surface engineering applications. It can be used to apply a coating in order to improve surface properties or to restore dimensions. The material selected for the coating has to be appropriate for the operating conditions of the component.
The application examples listed above are by no means blanket recommendations. The appropriate coating material, the suitability of the process and the expected service life all need to be established through engineering assessment and are defined in the relevant project specification.
Zinc Wire for Thermal Spray Metalizing
Zinc wire is the feedstock of choice for thermal spray metalising where molten zinc particles are deposited onto a suitably prepared steel substrate to provide atmospheric corrosion protection. It can be applied via arc spray or wire flame spray equipment. Performance of the coating is a function of the quality of the zinc, the quality of the surface preparation, the spray parameters, the coating thickness and the exposure environment.
How Is Zinc Wire Used in Thermal Spray Coating?
During zinc thermal spray metalising the zinc wire is fed continuously to the spray gun where it is heated until it melts. The molten zinc is then atomised into a spray of fine droplets which are projected onto the prepared steel surface. The droplets flatten out and build up to form a metallic zinc coating which provides protection to the steel substrate against corrosion.
The process generally involves:
- Selecting zinc wire suitable for the application and spray equipment.
- Cleaning and abrasive blasting the steel surface.
- Setting the equipment according to the specified process parameters.
- Feeding zinc wire into the spray gun.
- Melting and atomising the zinc.
- Applying successive passes to achieve the required coating thickness.
- Inspecting the coating and applying a suitable sealant if specified.
Why Is Zinc Used for Thermal Spray Metalizing?
Zinc provides sacrificial corrosion protection to steel under the right environmental conditions. If the coating is damaged locally and the steel is exposed, the zinc can corrode preferentially and thus protect the exposed steel. This is why zinc thermal spray coatings can be a viable option for certain infrastructure and industrial applications.
Common application areas include:
- Steel bridges and infrastructure
- Industrial buildings and structural steel
- Storage tanks and fabricated steel components
- Coastal and marine structures
- Other steel surfaces requiring atmospheric corrosion protection
The required zinc coating thickness and any sealing or additional coating treatment should be defined by the project specification.
Selecting the Right Zinc Wire
Choosing suitable zinc wire involves checking its material composition, diameter, dimensional consistency and compatibility with the spray equipment. The required wire specification should be matched to the intended coating process and application conditions.
Kothari Metsol offers zinc wire for industrial thermal spray metalizing applications. Buyers can refer to the zinc wire product page for relevant product information and suitability discussions.
Selecting the right feedstock is essential for achieving consistent thermal spray coating results. Factors such as zinc purity, wire diameter, surface condition and compatibility with the spray equipment should be checked before purchasing. Read our guide on selecting the right zinc wire for thermal spray coating to understand the important specifications and selection criteria.
Surface Preparation Before Thermal Spray Coating
Surface prep is absolutely critical for thermal spray coating as the deposited material is very much dependent on the condition of the substrate for adhesion. Oil, grease, rust, moisture and all the other sorts of contamination can have a negative effect on the coating. A clean surface, achieved by cleaning and appropriate abrasive blasting, will be roughened and will provide a surface for the sprayed particles to mechanically bond to the component.
Why Is Surface Preparation Important?
Thermo spray particles form a coating by flattening and building up on the prepared substrate. If the surface has any contaminants on it or doesn’t have the correct profile then you can end up with a coating that has poor adhesion, poor coverage or early failure. Proper surface preparation will go a long way to improving the consistency of the coating and will help to ensure that you get the performance that the specified coating system is designed to deliver.
Main Steps in Surface Preparation
1. Initial inspection
Inspect the component to identify corrosion, existing coatings, surface damage, oil deposits and other conditions that may affect coating application.
2. Degreasing and cleaning
Remove oil, grease and other contaminants using a suitable cleaning method. The surface should be free from residues that could interfere with abrasive blasting or coating adhesion.
3. Removal of rust and existing coatings
Remove rust, mill scale, loose paint and other unwanted surface layers using the specified preparation method.
4. Abrasive blasting
Use a suitable abrasive blasting process to achieve the required cleanliness and surface profile. The abrasive type, blasting pressure and preparation grade should follow the project specification.
5. Dust removal
Remove residual abrasive particles and dust using suitable cleaning equipment. Contamination left on the surface can affect coating quality.
6. Inspection before spraying
Check the prepared surface for cleanliness, profile and any visible contamination. Apply the coating within the specified time and environmental conditions to reduce the risk of flash rusting or recontamination.
Surface Preparation Checklist
| Inspection point | What should be checked |
| Cleanliness | No oil, grease or harmful contaminants |
| Rust and mill scale | Removed according to the specified preparation grade |
| Surface profile | Meets the coating specification |
| Dust | Residual abrasive and dust removed |
| Moisture | Surface condition meets environmental requirements |
| Timing | Spraying begins within the permitted interval after preparation |
The required preparation grade and surface roughness should be stated in the coating specification. For zinc and aluminium thermal spray corrosion-protection systems, the ISO 2063 series provides relevant guidance on coating execution and requirements.
Common Thermal Spray Coating Defects and How to Avoid Them
Thermal spray coating defects can occur because of poor surface preparation, incorrect spray parameters, contaminated feedstock, unsuitable application conditions or inadequate operator control. Common issues include poor adhesion, uneven coating thickness, excessive porosity, oxidation, rough surfaces and incomplete coverage. Identifying the causes early and following a documented application procedure helps reduce rework and improve coating consistency.
Common Defects, Causes and Prevention
| Coating defect | Possible causes | Prevention |
| Poor adhesion | Contaminated surface or inadequate surface profile | Clean and blast the substrate to the specified condition |
| Uneven thickness | Inconsistent spray distance, angle or movement | Maintain controlled spray technique and monitor thickness |
| Excessive porosity | Incorrect process parameters or unsuitable spray conditions | Optimise parameters and follow the approved procedure |
| Oxidation | Material overheating or unsuitable spray conditions | Control heat input and spray parameters |
| Rough or irregular coating | Incorrect feedstock, atomisation or operating settings | Check material condition and equipment settings |
| Uncoated areas | Poor spray coverage or incorrect gun positioning | Plan the spray sequence and inspect coverage |
| Dust inclusions | Contaminated surface or surrounding environment | Remove dust and maintain a clean work area |
| Cracking or flaking | Incompatible coating conditions, excessive thickness or substrate issues | Verify material compatibility and application requirements |
How to Prevent Thermal Spray Coating Defects
Maintain correct surface preparation: The substrate must meet the required cleanliness and roughness before spraying. Do not apply a coating over a contaminated or inadequately prepared surface.
Use compatible coating materials: Confirm that the feedstock is suitable for the spray equipment and the intended service conditions. Check material identification and condition before use.
Control spray parameters: Maintain the specified spray distance, angle, feed rate and operating settings. Avoid uncontrolled variations during application.
Monitor coating thickness: Measure thickness at defined stages rather than relying only on visual appearance. This helps identify uneven build-up before the job is completed.
Inspect equipment regularly: Check the spray gun, wire-feeding system, electrical connections, gas supply and compressed-air arrangements according to the equipment manufacturer’s instructions.
Follow a documented procedure: Use an approved coating procedure and maintain inspection records. For critical work, conduct a trial or procedure qualification where required.
Not every surface irregularity indicates coating failure. Defects should be assessed against the applicable specification and acceptance criteria before deciding whether repair or reapplication is necessary.
Standards, Quality Control and Inspection for Thermal Spray Coatings
Thermal spray coating standards provide guidance for process execution, material selection, personnel qualification and coating inspection. The applicable standard depends on the coating material and application. For zinc and aluminium corrosion-protection coatings, the ISO 2063 series is particularly relevant. A project specification should define coating thickness, adhesion requirements, surface preparation, acceptable imperfections and inspection methods.
Relevant Thermal Spray Standards
| Standard | Scope and relevance |
| ISO 2063-1 | Design considerations and requirements for thermal-sprayed zinc, aluminium and their alloys used for corrosion protection |
| ISO 2063-2 | Execution of corrosion-protection systems using thermal-sprayed zinc, aluminium and their alloys |
| ISO 14917 | Terminology and classification of thermal spraying processes |
| ISO 14918 | Qualification testing of thermal sprayers |
| ISO 14916 | Determination of tensile adhesive strength of thermally sprayed coatings |
| ISO 14921 | Procedures for applying thermally sprayed coatings to engineering components |
| ISO 14922 | Quality requirements for manufacturers of thermally sprayed coatings |
The applicable edition and any contractual or national requirements should be confirmed before specifying a standard. These standards have different scopes and should not be treated as interchangeable.
Important Quality Control Checks
1. Surface preparation inspection
Verify the cleanliness and surface profile before spraying. Check that the substrate meets the preparation requirements defined in the project specification.
2. Coating thickness measurement
Measure the deposited coating using a suitable calibrated thickness gauge. Take measurements at representative locations and compare the results with the specified minimum and any maximum thickness limits.
3. Adhesion testing
Where required, conduct an appropriate adhesion test to assess the bond strength of the coating. The test method and acceptance criteria should follow the applicable specification.
4. Visual inspection
Inspect the surface for bare areas, blisters, lumps, dust inclusions, flaking and other unacceptable imperfections.
5. Coating uniformity
Check that the coating is applied consistently across the required surface. Pay particular attention to edges, corners, recesses and difficult-to-access areas.
6. Documentation and traceability
Maintain records of coating material, equipment, process parameters, surface preparation, inspection results and any repair work.
Why Is Inspection Important?
Inspection confirms whether the applied coating meets the requirements established for the component and its service environment. It helps identify defects before the structure enters service and provides traceability for maintenance and future assessment. Inspection frequency and acceptance limits should be defined by the coating specification rather than applied as identical requirements to every project.
Safety and Environmental Considerations in Thermal Spray Coating
Thermal spray coating involves high temperatures, molten particles, compressed gases, electrical equipment and airborne fumes. Safe operation requires appropriate ventilation, equipment inspection, operator training and personal protective equipment. Arc spray and flame spray have different hazards, so their safety controls must reflect the equipment and energy sources used. Environmental management should also address fumes, dust, abrasive waste and coating residues.
Safety Requirements for Arc Spray
Arc spraying involves electrical equipment, compressed air, hot particles and airborne emissions. Operators should follow the equipment manufacturer’s instructions and site safety procedures.
Important precautions include:
- Inspect electrical cables, connections and power equipment before operation.
- Ensure proper grounding and electrical protection.
- Use suitable respiratory protection and effective local exhaust ventilation.
- Wear protective clothing, gloves, eye protection and a suitable welding or spraying helmet.
- Keep unauthorized personnel away from the spraying area.
- Control hot particles and potential ignition sources.
Safety Requirements for Flame Spray
Flame spraying uses fuel gases and oxygen, creating additional fire and gas-handling risks. Cylinders, regulators, hoses and connections must be maintained and used according to the applicable safety procedures.
Important precautions include:
- Secure gas cylinders in an upright position.
- Use suitable regulators, hoses and approved connections.
- Check for leaks before operating the equipment.
- Keep fuel gases and oxygen away from incompatible materials and ignition hazards.
- Provide adequate ventilation and appropriate fire protection.
- Shut down and isolate gas supplies according to the equipment procedure.
Environmental Considerations
Thermal spraying can generate metal fumes, dust, overspray and abrasive waste. The amount and type of emissions depend on the coating material, spray process and operating conditions. Work areas should have suitable extraction and waste-handling arrangements to reduce exposure and prevent uncontrolled release into the surrounding environment.
Environmental controls should include:
- Local exhaust ventilation and suitable filtration.
- Appropriate collection and disposal of abrasive blasting waste.
- Safe handling of unused coating material and metal residues.
- Proper storage of gas cylinders and consumables.
- Compliance with applicable workplace and environmental regulations.
- Regular maintenance of extraction and filtration systems.
A documented risk assessment should be completed before work begins. Operators should receive training specific to the selected spray process, materials and equipment.
Frequently Asked Questions
1. What is the main difference between arc spray and flame spray?
The main difference is the heat source used to melt the coating material. Arc spray uses an electrical arc between two conductive wires, while flame spray uses a fuel-gas combustion flame. Arc spraying generally offers higher deposition productivity for suitable metallic feedstock, whereas flame spraying provides flexibility in using wire, rod or powder.
2. Is arc spray better than flame spray?
Arc spray can be a better choice for applications requiring productive deposition of metallic coatings, particularly on larger steel surfaces. Flame spray may be more suitable for certain repair jobs or where different feedstock forms are required. The better option depends on coating specifications, substrate material, service conditions, equipment and project requirements.
3. What materials are used in arc spray coating?
Arc spray commonly uses electrically conductive metallic wires as its feedstock. Zinc, aluminium, stainless steel and other suitable metals or alloys may be selected depending on the equipment and application. Conventional twin-wire arc spraying requires conductive wires, while specialised cored-wire systems can support certain composite formulations.
4. What materials can be used in flame spray coating?
Flame spray equipment can process compatible materials supplied as wire, rod or powder. Depending on the system, feedstocks may include zinc, aluminium, nickel-based alloys, bronze and selected wear-resistant materials. The material must be suitable for the equipment and operating conditions, and its selection should be based on the required coating properties.
5. What is zinc thermal spray metalizing used for?
Zinc thermal spray metalizing is used to apply a zinc coating to suitable steel surfaces for atmospheric corrosion protection. It is commonly considered for infrastructure and industrial structures exposed to weather and moisture. The coating’s performance depends on surface preparation, application quality, thickness, sealing requirements and the surrounding environment.
6. Why is grit blasting required before thermal spray coating?
Grit blasting is commonly used to remove contaminants and create a rough surface profile that supports mechanical adhesion of the sprayed coating. A clean, suitably roughened substrate helps the deposited particles attach more effectively. The required preparation standard and surface profile depend on the coating material and project specification.
7. How do you choose between arc spray and flame spray?
Choose between arc spray and flame spray by evaluating the coating material, feedstock form, substrate, required coating properties and operating environment. Also consider surface area, deposition productivity, equipment access, cost and safety requirements. For critical structures, use an engineering-approved coating specification to establish the appropriate process and inspection criteria.
Conclusion
Arc spray and flame spray are established thermal spray coating processes used for metallic surface protection and selected component restoration applications. Arc spraying uses an electrical arc to melt two conductive wires, while flame spraying relies on a fuel-gas flame and can process different feedstock forms. Each method offers distinct advantages and limitations.
The right process depends on the coating material, component design, required coating characteristics, operating environment and project specifications. Careful material selection, proper surface preparation and quality inspection are essential for achieving reliable results.
Kothari Metsol, a zinc wire manufacturer in India, provides zinc wire and other metal-based product solutions relevant to industrial applications. For projects involving zinc thermal spray metalizing, selecting a suitable wire and matching it to the coating process are important steps in achieving the required surface protection.

